I'm aware of your train of thought Ray...enemies of the flag and all that.
The problem is "give them an inch". Once we publicly condone torture as being OK in the civilian justice system where does it end? Or does it just grow, like most things gov't gets its hands on? This is the type of policy that makes me tend to view the current fundamentalist/right-wing establishment as regressionists.
One of the things that is good about our country is the low number of torture/beating obtained confessions.