I just got back from The Green Turtle in Islamorada. I had a small fillet mignon, mash potato's and a mix of veggies. DELICIOUSIOSO. The meal came with the best bread sticks that had been cooked with a little bit of cheese on them, served with herb butter. The price was $ 14.00 which down here is super reasonable. Would that be a fair price where you are from? Mind you it was a petite fillet, but perfect for me.