I'll try out your setup and two others. I'm surprised how each setup differs and how the slightest change in almost anything has an impact on something.
Yes I have had a lot of issues with the HH not being consistent in grab it may be related to my climbing line. Setting the hitch is very important to getting it right. I found that if I weight it hard then collapse it it works well...but I think my technique for tying the HH knot needs work because when I weight the HH then take out the slack, the knot kind of rolls out a bit and I'm stuck with the same amount of slack that I just removed! It drives me nuts. I'm sure the issue is with the way I'm trying it..not the knot itself but my starting point in the line...something.
Thanks guys!
Hey, Chris! Apologies for not responding to this question sooner. I think I've posted my method for tying my hitch before on this forum, but I'll be darned if I can find it. It might be in the Rope Wrench thread. Trying to find it in order to avoid rewriting was the reason for the delay.
Anyway, I for some reason like to use the Knut hitch when I climb, but I think the method of tying I'm about to describe will work with any hitch. When I tie my hitches the way I'm about to describe, I never have to loosen up and re-tie the dog bone's stopper knots in order to remove slack.
So, I'm sitting in my folding chair, with my Hitch Hiker in front of me, with my climbing rope already passing through it. The straight spine of the Hitch Hiker is facing me, and the open, sloped channel that the rope sits in is facing away from me. I have one stopper knot already tied in the hitch cord going through the dog bone, and the dog bone is inserted into its slot in the Hitch Hiker.
Here is the key part to this whole operation, to me. I have the rope coming out of the top of the Hitch Hiker folded right over forward, so that it is basically laying right against the downward sloping edge of the rope channel. I do the wraps of my hitch cord around the rope, do my cross at the bottom if there is one, pass the end of the hitch cord through the other side of the dog bone, and try hard to pull out every last bit of slack from the hitch cord, while at the same time trying to create my second stopper knot.
At this point, if I've succeeded, what I'm left with is a hitch that is still folded over the sloped channel of the Hitch Hiker, and so darned tight and short that it is tough to even pull the hitch up so that it sits at the top of the Hitch Hiker. I end up having to pull the hitch up with my left hand, while at the same time I use my right hand to press hard on the back of the spine of the Hitch Hiker, to try to create enough pressure to drive the hitch to the top of the Hitch Hiker.
At this point, the hitch is so tight it hardly wants to tend at all. I stand up, and I pull up on the rope to try to tend it, while at the same time still pressing hard on the back of the spine of the Hitch Hiker. If I don't press hard on the back of the spine of the Hitch Hiker when I first try to tend slack, the hitch is so tight that it will naturally just roll right back down the sloped edge of the rope channel, which is something I wish to avoid. Pressing hard on the back of the spine of the Hitch Hiker while I'm pulling up on the rope, trying to tend it, forces the hitch to stay seated on the top, flat part of the Hitch Hiker. I'm walking forward on the ground ten or fifteen feet as I'm tending this slack. Once I've walked about as far as I can go without needing to leave the ground, I sit in my harness really hard, to try to "set" the hitch. Then I put two fingers on the top of the hitch and press down on it to get it to release, while at the same time walking backwards until I reach my starting point.
I repeat the procedure three or four times, pretty quickly, back and forth, and each time I do it the hitch gets easier to tend. By about the fourth time, the hitch is giving me almost no resistance to tending anymore.
The important part of this whole procedure, aside from getting the hitch to tend easily, is the fact that the hitch needs no further adjustment. I had it so tight and short at the beginning that there is no unwanted slack in the hitch cord at the end. It just works the way it is supposed to.
Sorry for the long-winded post, I'm just trying to adequately describe my process. I hope this is able to be of help to someone.
Tim
tags: setting, hitch, Hitch Hiker, slack, tending, vt, knut