I like the sound better, with fingers.  Used to like a harder sound that I got with a pick. 
I guess I have mellowed with age!  The Fender amp I destroyed by throwing it off the stage had and overdrive button, it was cool for a couple of days, but it wore off.  
So I play finger style now, with the brightest strings I can get.  My favorites were D'addario Prisms, but they quit making them.  You can make super bright stings sound mellow, but you cant brighten up mellow strings.