Jomo, I have that hook on my knuckle boom and we all hate it! Sure is secure though. Not sure how it is that much of a safety concern as we tie in to a friction saver above the ball
Thanks Mick, I enjoy tree work again!!
The safety concern's for the climber below the hook n rigging in the tree when the rigging on the hook snags in the canopy, upends the ball n hook, applying the weight of the ball onto the hook latch, and bending it outwards to the point of failure, allowing the rigging to free fall down onto the climber and potentially braining him.
I've seen it happen a few times and have to dodge the falling rigging.
That can't happen with the shur loc, even if you bounce the ball weight on the hook in any orientation, all day long.
Jomo