I agree with Andy on the scratches, but the upper ring does look a bit dinged up or cracked to the right of the locator pin. A little clearer here. Rings are cheap if that one is at all damaged and susceptible to breaking.. A broken ring will do serious damage to p and c, generally not something that can be buffed out. Are you sure that ring isn't broken? A ring doesn't generally sit tight against both sides of the locator pin when expanded. Something appears weird.